For some reason, as thoughts have been rattling around in my head this morning, a theme has emerged, along the lines of putting on my amateur-anthropologist hat and ponderiing how it is that religion becomes an element of every society. I know it’s often considered to be an institutionalized way for human beings to inquire into death, its meaning, and what might follow. Something occurred to me today, though, that I think is worth sharing: It may also be seen as an attempt to get a handle on just what human nature is and how to over come it.
The whole concept of focusing on the now, the present moment, has, like so much else worth looking into, been bastardized and trivialized in our modern culture. The New Age star du jour, Eckhardt Tolle, wrote a book a few years back called The Power of Now. The pop-culture interest in the subject actually goes back a few decades, through Ram Dass’s first book in 1970, Be Here Now, and on back to Alan Watts’s Beat Zen, Square Zen. But the notion of investigating the potential of now has a more serious pedigree; it forms the basis of Buddhism and Taoism.
The general idea is that all creation, all ongoing development of the universe, happens in the present moment. Who you are, what the blades of grass constituting your lawn are, and for that matter, what the rock at the corner of the flower bed is, can only be defined completely in this infinitesimal pinpoint on the trajectory of all multiplicity. What you were or what they were five minutes ago is merely the stuff of history.
I kind of think that’s why a lot of modes of spiritual inquiry, from New-Thought Christianity to Eastern thought to even the fluffiest forms of New Age-ism don’t have much to say about sin. If there’s only this universe full of particles in motion and they are what they are in any given snapshot, where’s the record book of transgressions against any human being for which he or she will be called to account?
Now, if it’s all just a matter of where things stand during this now, and this now, and this now, why can’t the human race choose a now, a particular moment, and, with everybody on board, just collectively drop all its problematic baggage - the stuff like lust, cruelty, brutality, greed, sloth, dishonesty - the stuff Western religion calls sin - as well as its anxiety and need to defend any number of things and its misplaced sense of what is valuable? Just drop it all and wipe the slate clean and begin anew?
Is there something about time that causes what we call human nature to kick in and make that impossible?
I think one reason we as a species could never pull that off is fear. It’s, to coin a term, human nature to hold in reserve in some little corner of our minds the concern that someone somewhere would not be on board and our dropped guard would spell our demise.
So the parade goes on. And permit yourself to kick this one around for a moment: any given snapshot of the parade, any of these nows, depicts a set of conditions brought on by the previous choices of human beings, who as often as not cut moral corners that led to the unplesant, even horrifying, parts of that snapshot. Now, any human being of any decency who has made such a choice - or, to put it differently, used his or her power of creation to bring about an unpleasant aspect of now - has, on some level, in however a minute degree, regret about having done so. And since there’s no stopping the space-time continuum to wipe the slate clean, cranking it back up again, and starting fresh in the same old realm, some other form of relief for that regret is necessary if there is any kind of resolution to human existence.
That brings us down to the question of whether you think there is any resolution to it or not. If you think there’s not, there’s no point to your decency.
I may have not thought this through with perfect thoroughness, but it looks to me like the only other possibility is a sovereign creator outside space and time, a creator who can grant us forgiveness. And that, of course, leads us back to the Western model for spirituality.
That’s about as far as I’ve gotten in this current train of thought, but I feel like I’ve gained ground that was still in front of me before today.