02.12.08
I could see this becoming a real time-eater
Several blogs have weighed in on the poll of high-school students fashioned by history professors from Stanford and the University of Maryland regarding the ten most famous Americans of all time. While the question “who do you think is most famous?” is rather unproductive (”No, this star sold more records!” “No, this politician was mentioned more times in newspaper articles!”), the top ten as pronounced by the poll results is a telling list. I would imagine the students actually went with what I would have gone with: who was most influential, or had the greatest impact on U.S. history. Still the answers are further justification for discouragement about the future of our society. There were some pretty dumb and off-the-wall selections. Oprah Winfrey? Marilyn Monroe?
Let’s throw it open here at BN. Let’s do use the “most influential” criterion. I don’t know how you’d measure fame or what tht would tell us that would be of any use.
So, I’ll kick things off. And, being the blogmeister, I reserve the right to post an entirely different list later based on changing my mind.
These aren’t necessarily in order.
Abraham Lincoln
Henry Ford
Dwight Eisenhower
W.C. Handy
John Dewey
Ralph Peer
Ezra Pound
Irving Berlin
David Sarnoff
Franklin Roosevelt
I can see already that I’ll be making another list. It’s a thought-provoking exercise.
In fact, let’s try it again.
Abraham Lincoln
George Washington
John Jay
Alexander Hamilton
James Madison
Thomas Jefferson
Henry Ford
Orville Wright
Wilbur Wright
Franklin Roosevelt
I’m sure I’ll be taking another crack at this.
In fact, let’s go again right now.
George Washington
Jonathan Edwards
Thomas Edison
William F. Buckley, Jr.
Ernest Hemingway
Louis Armstrong
Dwight Eisenhower
Walter Cronkite
Nathaniel Hawthorne
As you can see, my entries are not by any means all people I personally think are cool Cronkite, for example, makes it because he used the Tet Offensive in january 1968 – which was decidedly not a success for the Viet Cong – to convince the American public that U.S. involvement was a quagmire, which set off real momentum for the antiwar sentiment in this country, something that continues to mess us up to this day. John Dewey’s educational theories started us down the path of learner-centered education which paved the way for our present preoccupation with self-esteem.