The pathetic and poisonous efforts of the left to destroy Sarah Palin gives the lie to the meme that the oh-so-moderate chin-stroking urban/coastal chattering class has been trying to get us to swallow for a while: the notion that the culture wars were winding down and Americans were now more concerned with efficient delivery of health care and energy and other dry, arcane considerations.
The delicious irony is that it’s that sector of our society that, so far, has been the most shrill and murderous about the Palin candidacy. It’s the magazine writers, TV commentators and lefty bloggers who are pulling out all the stops in their attempt to wreck the governor’s career and life.
John Edwards was wrong about what comprised them, but he was right in his basic assertion that there are two Americas. The division is deeper than it’s ever been.
As a historian, I am interested in the roots of the schism. It certainly goes back farther than the 1960s. The New Left movement in academic circles got going in the 1940s and 50s with the works of William Appleman Williams and C. Vann Woodward. But the whole thing really goes back even further. There’s the Partisan Review crowd of the 1930s, Lillian Hellman, Walter Duranty’s puff-piece treatment of the USSR under Stalin. Maybe it goes back to the salons in the Greenwich Village brownstones of the turn of the century. American folk art is full of pairings of cousins, one a country bumpkin and one a city slicker, and I think that’s an element. One could even make the case that the Enlightenment, which originated in Europe, with its forthright reliance on rationality and empiricism, paved the way. In America, it led to a lot of offshoots from core Judeo-Christian thought, such as Unitarianism and the array of New Thought denominations. Also, here one would need to concede that even such Founding Fathers as the Deist Jefferson were looking into interpretive ways to relate to scripture. Still, relate to it he most definitely did.
In any event, at some point, a mindset ingrained itself into certain sectors of our society and spread to others. It was based on a divorce from a foundational and commonly held set of assumptions that had, up to that point, been part of American life in such a broad sense as to be considered universal. Church, family, gender differences, the relationship between industriousness and prosperity, sufficient understanding of human nature to make obvious the need for strong national defense - these were givens for pretty much everybody.
I was in the thick of the period when the Big Split became codified, when a sufficiently large plurality of citizens embraced it as to legitimize it in schools, workplaces and arenas of civic participation. I sat in the back of high school math class and read Ramparts magazine and Do It! by Jerry Rubin. I had shoulder-length hair, told my dad he was a fascist and a corporate fat cat. Spent days on end in the lysergic trenches. Made a point of running as far away from square old Jesus as I could and insisting that some kind of all-is-one state of so-called reality constituted ultimate truth.
So I bear some culpability for the current diseased state of our precious nation. What is so blessed about time, though, is that once you get smarter than you used to be, you can genuinely change. You can pick a moment and declare, “That’s not me anymore.”
The horror, the ghastliness, of what the enemy in the culture wars is attempting to do to Sarah Palin has been a wake-up slap across the face for me. I thought there was some tiny possibility that this was going to be a civil airing of differences, perhaps with some raised voices, close elections and strongly-worded polemics.
No, this is an actual war. My main encouragement about the odds for what is good and true prevailing stem from the resolve of those like the woman currently on the front line. I think tonight she will serve notice that she can outgun any comers.
Did you hear what she said in response to someone’s question about whether she’s up to this state of affairs? She posed a question and then answered it. “Do you know the difference between a pit bull and a hockey mom?” she asked. And then she said, “Lipstick.”